Changing times: the reorganisation of the abbey’s estates
By the thirteenth century the economic situation had changed. The
monks of Byland lived in a different world from that of their twelfth-century
predecessors and faced fresh challenges. Financial problems, the
Black Death, cattle
disease and warfare had all taken their toll, and the demise
of the lay-brotherhood at
this time meant there was a shortage of available manpower. Byland,
like other Cistercian
communities, had to rethink its estate management and had several
options: the monks could lease out their lands, repopulate vills
or engage hired help to work the abbey lands as demesne. Each of
these ran counter to the early ideals of the Order, but the General
Chapter accepted that there was some need to adapt with the
times and in 1208 it sanctioned the leasing of lands.(33)
The ravages of warfare
In 1344 Byland was permitted to appropriate Rillington, on
account of damage the community had suffered at the hands
of the Scots.
[Jennings, Yorkshire Monasteries, pp. 103-104.]
It generally made good business sense for the
community to lease out its remote lands, which could not easily
be brought into any
of the abbey’s estates. The community might lease out its
lands to lay-brothers or servants of the house. In September 1317,
Byland demised ten acres of land in Bretton to John of Dronfield,
for twenty years; John promised faithful aid in all business relating
to the house and agreed to pay the community three shillings biannually.(34) Granges
were often subdivided and might be leased to various members of
the same family.(35) The monastery
frequently forged good links with its tenants, but relationships
could be turbulent and Byland
clearly had its share of difficult tenants. One such trouble-maker
was William of Atton, who in 1369 was accused by the abbot of making
waste in the houses, woods and gardens that the community had demised
to him for ten years at Kirkby Malzeard.(36) Another
troublesome tenant was William Clayton, who in 1471 claimed to
hold rights (‘terms
and title of harmhold’) at Byland’s grange of Bentley
(Emley). The monks rubbished his claim and notified ‘all
Christian people’ that Thomas Allott was the true tenant
here, and that he, rather than William, should be supported.(37)
Byland continued to lease out its lands until
the end of the Middle Ages. An agreement was drawn up in 1532 between
Abbot John and
the monks of Byland and Richard Askywith of Osgoodby, regarding
the demise of a third of the monks’ grange at Osgoodby with
its appurtenances for ninety-nine years. It was decided that Richard
should pay the community 6m 8s 10 _ d twice a year. The abbot,
in return, granted Richard and his successors various rights to
hold during this period. Richard and his son agreed to maintain
and repair this third of the grange at their own cost, and to maintain
the straw roofs and plastered walls of the houses, ensuring that
these were handed over to the community in a good state of repair
at the end of the specified period.(38)
In the sixteenth century, on the eve of the
Dissolution, the Byland community significantly increased its rents.
Given that these were anxious and uncertain times this self-interest
is hardly surprising. Following the dissolution of Byland in 1538,
the precinct and many of the community’s former lands were
sold to Sir William Pickering of Oswaldkirk. William died soon
thereafter and was succeeded by his son, Sir William Pickering
II. In 1574 the lands passed to the Wottons. Today, farms now stand
on many sites formerly occupied by Byland’s granges, such
as Oldstead Grange, which lies about a mile to the north-west of
the abbey ruins. At some sites earthworks are still visible, for
example, in the paddocks at Cams Head Farm, which stands to the
west of the abbey.