'rotten from the soles of his feet to the
crown of his head.’
[Bernard ‘of Clairvaux’s verdict on William FitzHerbert]
William was at the centre of controversy in
1142, when King Stephen (1135-1154) appointed him archbishop of
York. William’s opponents included the Cistercians, who accused
him of simony and unchaste living, and sought his removal from
office. Bernard of Clairvaux wrote to
the pope, Innocent II, denouncing FitzHerbert as 'rotten from the
soles of his feet to the crown
of his head.' (1) The abbots of Fountains and Rievaulx, Richard and
William, voiced their opposition
and joined a delegation to Rome in 1143. When Henry
Murdac succeeded to the abbacy of Fountains,
he played an active role in opposing William. This had serious
repercussions for Fountains, and in 1146 William’s supporters
launched a violent attack on the abbey, burning the buildings.
The following year William was deposed by the Cistercian pope,
Eugenius III, who installed Henry Murdac to the see of York. This
new appointment provoked an outrage and many, including King Stephen
and the bishop of Winchester, refused to acknowledge the new archbishop.
Murdac was forced to spend five of his six years as archbishop
in Ripon.
Following Henry's death in 1153, William was
reinstalled as archbishop and made his peace with the Fountains
community.
He asked for the
monks’ forgiveness, confirmed their possessions and exchanged
the kiss of peace, thereby restoring harmony between Fountains
and the see of York. William did not, however, remain long in office.
He died only a few weeks later and it was rumoured that poison
had been put in the chalice he used to celebrate the Mass. Miracles
were reported at William’s tomb, and following an investigation
led by the abbots of Fountains and Rievaulx, William was canonized
in 1227, by Pope Honorius III. The magnificent William window in
York Minster today commemorates the saint.