... they obtain from a rich man a valueless
and despised plot in the heart of a great wood, by much feigning
of innocence and long importunity, putting in God at every other
word. The wood is cut down, stubbed up and levelled into a plain,
bushes give place to barley, willows to wheat, withies to vines;
and it may be that to give them full time for these operations,
their prayers have to be somewhat shortened.
[Walter Map, De Nugis Curialium] (12)
Ruthless predators
The Cistercians were portrayed by their critics as ruthless predators,
who would drive out peasant settlements to make way for their cultivation
of the land. Whilst this certainly did occur in places – indeed
Fountains depopulated vills at Cayton, Herleshow and Thorpe Underwood
to establish granges -this was not carried out on the scale suggested
by their critics. Moreover, the natives might actually benefit from
such an occurrence if the relocation was favourable, or if they either
received employment from the abbey or admission as a lay-brother of
the house.
[Coppack, Fountains Abbey, p. 105; Williams, The Cistercians
in the Early Middle Ages, p. 278.]
During the twelfth century the Cistercians earned a reputation
for greediness, with complaints that in their pursuit of land they
would beg, bargain, deceive and, if need be, use force. The damning accounts
by
their critics, chiefly the satirists Walter Map and Gerald of Wales,
undoubtedly exaggerate the truth, but, as complaints from the Cistercians’ supporters
and indeed rulings from the General
Chapter suggest, their remarks
were not wholly unfounded. The Cistercians in England – and the monks
of Fountains – were clearly eager to pursue their interests, but their
acquisitiveness should perhaps be attributed as much to shrewdness
as much to greediness.
Many of the grants made to Fountains were by laymen
and women wishing
to make provision for their souls. They included great magnates,
such as Roger de Mowbray and
William de Stuteville, and those of more humble means,
for example, Robert, who was the local glazier of Ingerthorpe.(13) The
majority of benefactors, however, came from knightly families,
for example, the Mohauts
and Plumptons.(14)