The complexity of administering the abbey’s lands
and resources in the thirteenth century meant an increase in disputes
and litigation. In 1202 Byland lodged a number of complaints against
John, son
of Harding, including allegations of violence against Brother Richard
of Studley, a member of the Byland community. The matter was brought
to the
royal and archiepiscopal courts, and an agreement was drawn up
whereby John quitclaimed land to the monks in Osmundfiniac.(50) In
1239 the abbot of Byland sued Peter de Brus for eight thousand
haddocks. Peter, it seems,
had agreed to pay the abbot one thousand haddocks a year, but was
eight years in arrears.(51) There
were allegations made against the community too. In 1244 the knight,
Nicholas de Boteby, complained that the abbot of Byland
had carried away
the timber and bush he had cut in his wood at Boteby; the case
was brought to court.(52)
Byland also engaged in disputes with other religious,
including its fellow Cistercians at Fountains. The two communities
had rival interests in Nidderdale, which each had been given by
the great magnate, Roger
de Mowbray.(53) Conflict
here began in the late twelfth century
and continued until c. 1260.(54) In
the 1220s the two communities came to blows over their respective
rights to mines in Nidderdale. The
General Chapter denounced this bickering as a disgrace to the Order,
and
nominated
Abbot Roger of Rievaulx and the abbots of Furness and Beaulieu to settle this dispute.(55)
In 1278-81, Byland claimed the right to hold
its own assize court
in its manor house at Clifton, just outside York. Crimes committed
within the monks’ liberty were heard at Clifton, and surviving
rolls suggest that these were mostly petty offences, such as the
theft of a silver
spoon from Ampleforth and of opportunists who stole goods amounting
to twenty shillings during the Scots invasion of 1322.(56) The
manor house at
Clifton was evidently a remarkable building, both in size and function.
The great hall was the equal of any episcopal residence, and the
house seems to have accommodated the royal household, including
Edward II (1307-1327),
and was the setting for a secret rendez-vous. [Read more about this fascinating property]